I Inherited a House, What To Do? – Should I Rent or Sell in Massachusetts?

Inherited a House


Inheriting a house can be both a blessing and a dilemma rolled into one. On one hand, you have a valuable asset at your disposal, but on the other, you’re confronted with a range of choices about what to do with it. This decision can be emotionally complicated, as the property may hold sentimental value. It’s also practically complicated, given the myriad of financial factors involved. The state of Massachusetts, with its vibrant property market and unique laws, adds another layer of complexity to the decision. Let’s dig deeper into the various considerations that can guide you toward making the best choice for your specific situation.

Emotional and Practical Considerations: The Starting Point

First things first. An inherited house often comes with emotional baggage that might cloud your judgment. Whether it’s the house you grew up in or a place where you spent countless holidays, emotional ties can be strong. Acknowledge these emotions but try to separate them from the financial and practical aspects of what comes next.

On a practical level, consider the following:

  • Condition of the House: Is it in move-in condition, or does it require significant repairs?
  • Location: Is the house located in an area where property values are likely to increase?
  • Your Capability: Do you have the time and skills needed to manage a rental property?

These considerations set the stage for the more detailed financial analysis to come.

The Pros and Cons of Renting: A Closer Look


  1. Steady Income Stream: One of the most compelling reasons to rent out an inherited property is the prospect of a consistent monthly income.
  2. Property Appreciation: If the house is in a growing area, it could appreciate in value, potentially offering you a double financial gain—rental income plus increased equity.
  3. Tax Benefits: From deductions for repairs to depreciation, rental properties offer several tax advantages.


  1. Property Management Burden: Renting out property isn’t a hands-off investment. It requires time, effort, and money for maintenance, repairs, and tenant management.
  2. Legal Risks and Complexities: The Massachusetts landlord-tenant laws are comprehensive and favor tenants in many cases. Ignorance of the law is not an excuse and could land you in hot water.
  3. Market Volatility: Economic downturns can affect both rental income and property value. Ensure you can weather these fluctuations.

The Pros and Cons of Selling: More Than Just Cash in Hand


  1. Liquidity: Unlike renting, selling the property translates to a significant lump sum that can be invested elsewhere or used to meet immediate financial goals.
  2. Less Hassle: No tenants, no maintenance, no ongoing property taxes or insurance—selling can feel like lifting a weight off your shoulders.
  3. Potential for Capital Gains: If the property has appreciated since you inherited it, a sale can lead to a substantial profit.


  1. Capital Gains Tax: Profit from the sale could be subject to capital gains tax, although inheritance usually comes with a stepped-up basis that could reduce this liability.
  2. Transaction Costs: From realtor fees to closing costs, selling isn’t free.
  3. Timing the Market: The best time to sell a property is often dictated by market conditions, which are out of your control.

Massachusetts-Specific Factors: What You Need to Know

Market Health

Massachusetts, particularly areas like Boston, has seen a generally robust real estate market. However, property values and rental rates can differ significantly from one locality to another.

Legal Landscape

Understanding Massachusetts property law is critical. For example, tenant-friendly laws can make the rental process more challenging. Conversely, the state also has rules that could benefit sellers.

Financial Analysis: Crunching the Numbers

A solid financial analysis should be the cornerstone of your decision. Consider long-term maintenance costs, property tax hikes, and potential rent increases. On the selling side, consult professionals to get an accurate estimate of the property’s value and weigh this against any impending costs like repairs or capital gains tax.


Inheriting a house in Massachusetts poses both emotional and financial challenges, leaving you with significant decisions to make—namely whether to rent or sell the property. Trade Property For Cash can serve as your guiding partner through this complex terrain. Whether you decide to take advantage of the rental market or opt for the liquidity of a sale, we offer tailored solutions to fit your unique circumstances, including fast and fair cash offers for immediate property sales. Take the first step toward making an informed decision that aligns with both your heart and your wallet by contacting Trade Property For Cash today.

Just call us today at 508-850-0339 or contact us now for more information
on how we can make you a fair cash offer on your inherited house today!

Get More Info On Options To Sell Your Home...

Selling a property in today's market can be confusing. Connect with us or submit your info below and we'll help guide you through your options.

Get An Offer Today, Sell In A Matter Of Days...

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *